Skip to content
A roulette wheel and stacked casino chips on dark green felt beside a brass balance scale, lit by one warm lamp.

Analysis · 10 min

Same game, different rules: how states limit gambling, what it costs players and who earns from it

16 Nov 2026 ·

A roulette wheel and stacked casino chips on dark green felt beside a brass balance scale, lit by one warm lamp. · Bonusjungle illustration

We compared how 12 countries regulate online casino games and what they allow in their own casinos. In Germany we also counted: 776 games at one licensed site return about 87% to the player on average, where the maker lists 96.5% for the same game. Facts first, our opinion after, clearly marked.

Most countries now limit online gambling in the name of player protection. We wanted to know two things. Do the same limits apply where the state itself runs, licenses or taxes the game? And what do the limits cost the player in practice?

This report has two parts. Part one is facts, with sources. Part two is our opinion, and it is marked as opinion. Germany gets the closest look because it is the market we know best and because its rules are published in detail. It is one example among several, not the exception.

The short version

  1. Germany applies three different rulebooks to the same slot game, depending on where it stands: the private arcade, the licensed website or the state-licensed casino.
  2. Online, Germany taxes every stake at 5.3%. With the payout rates usual elsewhere, that sum does not add up, so German players get lower-paying versions of the same games.
  3. In our sample of 776 games at one German site, about 87% reaches the player on average. The maker lists 96.5% for one of those games.
  4. For the player, €100 lasts a little over an hour instead of almost four.
  5. The pattern is international. States tend to be strict where private firms offer the game and more generous where the state is owner, licensor or main earner.

Newest casinos

18+ · Affiliate links. We may earn a commission.

Group 1: One game, three rulebooks in Germany

The left and middle columns come from the law. Entries marked "our experience" are what we have seen ourselves as players and are not taken from a rulebook.

Private arcadeOnline, German licenceCasino (Spielbank)
Maximum stake per game€0.20€1; since July 2026 up to €5 on requestNo figure in the law. The casino sets it. Our experience: usually €20, sometimes €50
SpeedAt least 5 secondsAt least 5 secondsNo rule found
AutoplayNo (our experience)BannedYes (our experience)
Loss or deposit limit€60 loss per hour€1,000 in deposits per monthNone found
Forced break5 minutes after one hour5 minutes after one hourNone found
JackpotsBannedBannedNo ban found

Three notes on the table:

  • The €1,000 limit counts deposits, not losses. Money withdrawn in the same month is not offset. The limit can be raised on request, up to €10,000 and in exceptions up to €30,000, according to the regulator's FAQ.
  • The arcade rules do not apply to casinos. The trade law says so in terms (Section 33h of the Gewerbeordnung). In Bavaria, the casino sets its own minimum and maximum stakes and posts them at the table and the machine (Section 8 of the Spielbankordnung).
  • The regulator has loosened the online stake itself. Since 1 July 2026 the Gemeinsame Glücksspielbehörde der Länder (GGL) allows up to €3 from age 21 and up to €5 after 90 days of play without warning signs, limited until the end of 2027. Operators do not have to offer it.

These rules are written by the 16 German states in their gambling treaty and by the federal tax law. The GGL applies them. It also publishes them in plain language, which is why we can compare them at all.

Group 2: The stake tax and the payout rate

Germany taxes online slot play at 5.3% of every stake, win or lose (Sections 37 and 38 of the Rennwett- und Lotteriegesetz). The tax base is the stake minus the tax, which comes to about 5 cents per euro staked.

Per €1 staked
Tax to the stateAbout 5 cents
What the operator keeps at a 96% payout rate4 cents
ResultA loss on every spin. The payout rate has to fall.

Our sample: 776 games at one German site. On 16 November 2026 we read the table in which BingBong, a German-licensed site, publishes the payout rate (RTP) of every game it offers.

The operator writes, in our translation: "Most providers in Germany pass the 5.3% tax on to their players in a hidden way, by offering slots with a reduced payout rate." BingBong takes 7.2% of every win instead.

MakerGamesListed payout rate (median)Reaching the player after the 7.2% deduction
Novomatic (Greentube)16390.1%About 83.6%
Merkur11094.1%About 87.3%
Pragmatic Play5694.5%About 87.7%
All games77694.0%About 87.2%

The right-hand column is our calculation (listed rate times 0.928), not the operator's figure. The weakest game comes to about 79%. After the deduction, 43% of the games are below 85%.

The same game, two rates. Pragmatic Play lists its standard payout rate on its own website.

GameMaker's standard rateReaching the player in our German sample
Gates of Olympus96.50%About 87.7%
Sweet Bonanza96.48%About 88.6%
Big Bass Bonanza96.71%About 87.3%
The Dog House96.51%About 88.6%

Limits of the sample: it is one operator, not the market. We did not read a maker's standard rate for Novomatic or Merkur at the source. We have not yet counted a site that lowers the rate itself instead of deducting from wins.

Group 3: What it costs the player

All figures are expected values at 5 seconds per spin. They are our calculation. A single evening can go better or worse.

One evening: €100, €1 per spin

Payout rate reaching the playerPlaying timeLoss per €100 stakedLeft after the money has been played through 20 times
96.5% (maker's standard)Almost 4 hours€3.50€49.00
87.7% (our German sample)68 minutes€12.30€7.20
80%42 minutes€20.00€1.20

Playing time falls by a factor of 3.5. Because players keep playing with what comes back, the gap in what is left grows with every pass. After 20 passes it is almost sevenfold.

One month: €1,000, the German deposit limit

Payout rate reaching the playerPlaying time at €1 per spinPlaying time at €0.20 per spin
96.5% (maker's standard)39.7 hours198 hours
87.7% (our German sample)11.3 hours56.5 hours
80%6.9 hours34.7 hours

Where the €1,000 goes, with a 5.3% tax on every stake

Payout rate reaching the playerTotal staked from €1,000TaxState's share of the player's loss
96.5% (maker's standard)€28,571About €1,440More than the whole loss
87.7% (our German sample)€8,130About €41041%
80%€5,000About €25025%

The first row shows why the standard rate cannot be offered under a stake tax: the tax would be higher than everything the player loses. One caution: the tax row uses the statutory tax on stakes. The operator in our sample deducts from wins instead, so the amount that reaches the state there may differ.

Group 4: How other countries do it

The score for self-determination runs from 1 (the state decides almost everything) to 5 (the adult decides almost everything). It is our own assessment, not a measurement.

A. The state is the provider, or only its licensees may play online

CountrySituationScore
NorwayState monopoly. The regulator blocks other sites1
FinlandMonopoly until 30 June 2027, licences from 1 July 20272
AustriaOne online concession today. A bill would open the market with deposit caps of €250 a week under 26 and €1,680 a month from 262
SwitzerlandOnline only for land-based casinos with an extended concession2

B. Online casino banned, other gambling allowed

CountrySituationScore
FranceOnline casino games are not legal. Sports betting, horse racing and poker are2
AustraliaThe Grattan Institute puts losses at A$1,635 per adult a year, the highest in the world, and says about 93% of the country's 185,000 poker machines stand outside casinos2
BrazilSince October 2026 a decree bans fixed-odds betting and online casino. Other lotteries allowed by law are exempt1

C. Allowed, with hard state limits

CountrySituationScore
GermanySee groups 1 to 32
NetherlandsChecks from €700 net deposits a month. The regulator says licensed revenue fell 21% in 2025; the licensed share of revenue was an estimated 59% in the first half of 20263
ItalyThe 2027 budget bill plans €700m more from gambling3

D. The same rule everywhere, or the player decides

CountrySituationScore
United Kingdom£5 per spin online, and £5 on casino slot machines (category B1)4
SpainFrom 26 March 2027 one default limit across all operators: €700 a day4

Group 5: The case for the limits

  • Germany's regulator says it sees no valid signs that problem gambling has changed significantly since 2023. Supporters read that as the rules working.
  • The German deposit limit is not absolute. It can be raised after checks.
  • The United Kingdom shows that a state can apply the same stake limit online and in its casinos.
  • A UK Gambling Commission study found that among people with repeated payments to suspected illegal sites, 45% of those surveyed scored as problem gamblers. Unregulated play is not harmless.
  • Most black-market estimates come from the industry itself and should be read with care.
  • Our payout sample is one operator.

Our view

This section is comment. It is the opinion of Bonusjungle.

In many countries, the state holds the bank. In a casino, the bank wins in the end. In gambling policy the state often sits in that seat. It writes the rules, hands out the seats at the table and takes a share of every game. In several countries it also plays. The stated reason is player protection, and we do not doubt that many people who write these rules mean it. But the results follow a pattern, and the pattern is about money as much as about risk.

The limits follow the money. If risk were the only measure, the same game would have the same limit everywhere. Norway keeps the game for its own company. France and Australia ban the online casino and keep taxing casinos and machines. Brazil closed private betting and exempted lotteries. Germany is strictest in the private arcade and most relaxed in the casino its states license. The risk to the player does not shrink because the carpet is thicker.

A stake tax makes the game worse. We think this is the most important finding. A tax on every stake leaves operators little choice but to sell players a lower-paying version of the same game: same name, same pictures, lower return. The loss in a game of chance is certain anyway. Under a stake tax the player gets far less playing time for the same loss. A player who loses faster is not better protected. As consumers, players in such a market are worse off than players of the same game elsewhere.

A deposit limit is not a loss limit. A limit that counts deposits treats the player who won, withdrew and wants to play again like the player who lost everything. We think a limit should protect the person who is losing.

What we have seen in casinos. In our own experience in German casinos, a guest can feed large notes into a machine, run autoplay at €20 a spin and place very large single bets at the roulette table, with no monthly limit. We are told staff are trained to watch for problem play. Online, a €1,000 limit applies to everyone, including players who are ahead. That is hard to explain by risk alone.

What we do not claim. We do not say limits are wrong. Online slots are fast, always available and dangerous for some people. We do not say there is bad faith behind every rule, and we do not blame the authorities who apply rules that parliaments wrote. We say this: whoever earns from the game should not be the only one who decides how much others may play.

Overview and our yardstick

The claimWhat we foundGroup
Low stakes protect the player€0.20 in the arcade, €1 online, no figure in the law for casinos1
The monthly limit caps lossesIt counts deposits. We found none for casinos1
The tax is paid by operatorsIt is passed on through lower payout rates, as one operator says itself2
Regulated games are fair valueAbout 87% reaches the player, against 96.5% for the same game2
The rules slow the game down€100 lasts 68 minutes instead of almost 4 hours3
The state protectsWith a stake tax, about 41 cents of every euro lost goes to the treasury3
Online is the special dangerWhere the state provides the game or taxes it on site, more is allowed4

Our yardstick

  • Same game, same rule. What is too risky online cannot be unlimited in a casino.
  • Tax the operator's revenue, not the stake. Then players get the same game as everyone else.
  • Measure losses, not deposits.
  • Let adults set their own limit, and apply it to every provider, state-owned ones included.

18+. Gambling can be addictive. If it stops being fun, see our responsible gambling page.

Sources