Skip to content
A closed wooden courtroom door with brass handles at the end of a stone corridor.

Regulation · 5 min

EU court leaves Malta's Bill 55 undecided: the Austrian court's questions are inadmissible

19 Nov 2026 ·

A closed wooden courtroom door with brass handles at the end of a stone corridor. · Bonusjungle illustration

The EU Court of Justice ruled on 19 November 2026 that the questions an Austrian court sent it about Malta's Bill 55 are inadmissible. It did not say whether the law, which blocks certain foreign judgments against Malta-licensed gambling operators, fits EU law. The question stays open.

The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on 19 November 2026 that the request for a preliminary ruling in Case C-683/24, Spielerschutz Sigma, is inadmissible. The court did not decide whether Malta's "Bill 55" is compatible with EU law.

Bill 55 added Article 56A to the Maltese Gaming Act in June 2023. It tells Maltese courts to refuse certain foreign judgments against gambling operators that hold a Maltese licence. Players in Austria and other countries who have won repayment of their losses in court therefore still have no answer from Luxembourg on whether Malta may block the collection of that money.

Newest casinos

18+ · Affiliate links. We may earn a commission.

What the court decided

The court gave one reason: an answer to the questions is not needed to decide the case in Vienna.

A national court may only send questions to Luxembourg if it needs the answer to decide the dispute in front of it. The court says there must be a link between the dispute and the EU rules in question, and that link "must be real and concrete, not purely hypothetical, theoretical or speculative".

The Vienna case is about a legal adviser's liability, not about enforcing a judgment in Malta. Under Austrian law, the question there is whether the adviser's opinion was "at the very least reasonably defensible" in the light of the law and the information available when it was written. If it was, for example because it matched at least part of the case-law or legal writing, the adviser is not liable.

The court concludes that the rights and duties of the parties to that advice contract do not depend on whether the Maltese law fits EU law. The questions therefore asked for "advisory opinions on general or hypothetical questions".

What the Austrian court had asked

The Handelsgericht Wien (Commercial Court, Vienna) referred several questions. According to the court's press releases, they come down to one issue: is a national rule like Article 56A compatible with EU law, and in particular with the Brussels I bis Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012), which makes civil judgments from one member state enforceable in the others?

Under Article 56A, Maltese courts must refuse, as a matter of public policy, to recognise or enforce a foreign judgment that does three things at once:

  • it upholds a claim against a gaming operator with a Maltese licence,
  • it is based on the operator's services being illegal in another member state,
  • and those services were lawful under Maltese law.

The court's press release of 19 November describes the 2023 amendment more broadly: it also bars such actions against Malta-licensed operators themselves.

We have not read the exact wording of the questions. The court's press release does not print them.

How the case got here

DateStep
24 April 2023Bill 55 is tabled in Malta's parliament
June 2023It becomes law as the Gaming (Amendment) Act 2023 and adds Article 56A to the Gaming Act
After June 2023Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian company that funds players' court claims, asks a legal adviser whether the amendment fits EU law. The adviser concludes it is manifestly in conflict with EU law and will not be applied in enforcement proceedings in Malta
LaterA Maltese court refuses to recognise and enforce an Austrian judgment, relying on the amendment
ThenSpielerschutz Sigma sues the adviser for damages before the Commercial Court in Vienna. It wants its fee back and compensation for proceedings it funded after the opinion
2024The Vienna court's questions are registered at the Court of Justice as Case C-683/24
23 April 2026Advocate General Nicholas Emiliou proposes to find the reference inadmissible. In case the court disagrees, he adds that a rule like Article 56A is "manifestly incompatible" with Brussels I bis
19 November 2026The court (Fourth Chamber) rules that the reference is inadmissible

The press releases give no exact dates for the adviser's opinion, the Maltese decision or the Vienna lawsuit.

What the ruling means, and what it does not

It is not a win for Bill 55. The court did not say that Article 56A is lawful. It said nothing on the substance.

It is not a ruling against Bill 55 either. The Advocate General's view that the rule is manifestly incompatible with EU law stays what it was: an opinion. It does not bind the court or any national court.

The court followed its Advocate General on the first point only. He had proposed inadmissibility for the same reason. The court stopped there and did not take up his second, substantive part.

For players, nothing changes today. A player who has won a repayment judgment in Austria against a Malta-licensed operator is in the same position as yesterday. Maltese courts can still rely on Article 56A when asked to enforce such a judgment.

What to expect now

This section is our assessment. It is not part of the judgment.

  • The Vienna case goes on without an answer from Luxembourg. The Commercial Court now has to decide the adviser's liability under Austrian law. The Court of Justice has in effect told it what matters there: whether the opinion was reasonably defensible at the time.
  • The question about Article 56A is likely to come back. It was turned away because of the kind of case it arrived in, not because it is unimportant. A reference from a case in which a court actually has to decide on recognising or enforcing such a judgment would not have this problem. We do not know of a pending reference of that kind and have not checked.
  • Other routes exist. EU law can also be tested through proceedings brought by the European Commission against a member state. We have not checked the current status of any such proceedings on Bill 55 and make no claim about them.
  • Expect both sides to claim the result. Operators can say the law stands. Claimant lawyers can point to the Advocate General. Neither has a ruling on the substance.
  • We make no forecast on timing. A new reference would normally take more than a year from referral to judgment. This case took about two.

Our earlier story set out three ways the ruling could go. It went the first way.

18+. Gambling can be addictive. If you want to take a break, see our responsible gambling page.

Sources